National Disaster Policy: Criticism of the State's Response to the Disaster in West Sumatra
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.32663/8hfz0p24Kata Kunci:
Critical Policy Analysis, Disaster Politics, The State in Society, West SumatraAbstrak
The determination of national disaster status in Indonesia is frequently misconstrued as a purely technocratic decision governed by objective metrics of casualties and material loss. This article challenges that positivist assumption by analyzing the state's refusal to elevate the status of the May 2024 cold lava flood (galodo) in West Sumatra, despite catastrophic damage that exceeded regional fiscal capacities. Utilizing a Critical Policy Analysis (CPA) framework synthesized with Joel Migdal's State-in-Society theory, this study demonstrates that disaster status determination functions as a political mechanism for fiscal preservation and the management of central-regional power relations. The analysis reveals three primary policy patterns: (1) the discursive manipulation of legal definitions regarding "government paralysis" to avoid statutory obligations; (2) the deployment of "politics of survival" strategies to protect the central state budget from unlimited liability; and (3) the depoliticization of ecological causality to shield extractive political-economic interests from scrutiny. The findings indicate that the current disaster governance regime operationalizes a logic of containment that subordinates social justice to macro-political stability, effectively shifting the burden of recovery to peripheral local governments with limited resources. This article concludes that without structural reform to the legal framework specifically the objectification of disaster indicators the state will continue to perpetuate structural inequalities through discretionary exclusion
Unduhan
Referensi
Akinbi, I. J., & Oluwole, L. (2025). Peace-informed development planning: Aligning human security, infrastructure investment, and conflict sensitivity in fragile states post-conflict societies. International Journal of Science and Research Archive, 15(02), 676–694.
Aoki, N. (2023). Fiscal Decentralization And Disaster Mitigation: Evidence From The Philippines. The University of Tokyo.
Ariyaningsih, Sukmara, R. B., Bachtiar, R., Iriansyah, A. A., & Shaw, R. (2025). Disaster Law in Indonesia. In Disaster Law: Implications to Governance and Implementation (pp. 183–205). Springer.
Assegaf, U. F. (2020). Alkhairaat: A Study on Its Hadhrami Background and Roles in Educational Reform in Eastern Indonesia. The Australian National University (Australia).
BNPB. (2025). BNPB Perkirakan Estimasi Biaya Perbaikan Bencana di Sumatera Capai Rp51,82 Triliun. Merdeka.Com. https://www.merdeka.com/politik/bnpb-perkirakan-estimasi-biaya-perbaikan-bencana-di-sumatera-capai-rp5182-triliun-505099-mvk.html?page=3
Cambridge University Press. (2015). The Rebel State in Society: Governance and Accommodation in Aceh, Indonesia. 05 October. https://www.cambridge.org/core/books/abs/rebel-governance-in-civil-war/rebel-state-in-society-governance-and-accommodation-in-aceh-indonesia1/528A9E7A226A68F86BB3EFA4F55B339D
Chandra, R. (2024). BPBD Sebut Kerugian Sementara Bencana Banjir Lahar Dingin Gunung Marapi di Sumbar Rp 108,38 Miliar. Sumbar.Suara.Com. https://sumbar.suara.com/read/2024/05/20/111652/bpbd-sebut-kerugian-sementara-bencana-banjir-lahar-dingin-gunung-marapi-di-sumbar-rp-10838-miliar
Chomsky, N. (2020). Rogue states: The rule of force in world affairs. Haymarket Books.
Cummings, S., De Haan, L., & Seferiadis, A.-A. (2020). How to use critical discourse analysis for policy analysis: a guideline for policymakers and other professionals. Knowledge Management for Development Journal, 15(1), 99–108.
De Rivera, L. P. (2022). The conditions of inclusion: Interrogating the rhetoric of global Disaster Risk Reduction (DRR) policy texts on knowledge integration and inclusion. International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction, 81, 103280.
Deportes, I., Wicaksono, W., Desportes, I., & Wicaksono, W. (2024). A Multiplicity of Socio-Historically Grown Distaster Cultures in Indonesia.
Drake, C. (2019). National integration in Indonesia: Patterns and policies. University of Hawaii Press.
Edelman, D. J. (2023). Management of the Urban Environment in Three Southeast Asian Coastal Metros: Bangkok, Manila and Jakarta. Advances in Applied Sociology, 13(10), 765–839.
encyclopedia. (2024). 2024 West Sumatra floods. Wikipedia.Org. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2024_West_Sumatra_floods
Fachri Hamzah. (2025). Walhi West Sumatra: Floods Are an Ecological Crisis, Not a Mere Natural Disaster. En.Tempo.Co. https://en.tempo.co/read/2072968/walhi-west-sumatra-floods-are-an-ecological-crisis-not-a-mere-natural-disaster
Falco, G. (2019). Cybersecurity principles for space systems. Journal of Aerospace Information Systems, 16(2), 61–70.
Fia Hamid-Walker. (2025). Should Prabowo declare the Sumatra flood a national disaster? And does it really matter? Indonesiaatmelbourne.Unimelb.Edu.Au. https://indonesiaatmelbourne.unimelb.edu.au/should-prabowo-declare-the-sumatra-flood-a-national-disaster-and-does-it-really-matter/
Financial Protection Forum. (2025). Global Shield Financing Facility Impact Story. Financialprotectionforum.Org. https://www.financialprotectionforum.org/blog/global-shield-financing-facility-impact-story-supporting-governments-ambitious-disaster-risk
Financing Disaster Resilience in Indonesia: Assessing the Landscape and Charting Path Forward. (n.d.).
Fischer, F. (2021). Truth and post-truth in public policy. Cambridge University Press.
Geddes, B. (2023). Politician’s dilemma: building state capacity in Latin America (Vol. 25). Univ of California Press.
Gretskiy, I. (2023). Is There Life in the Desert?: Russian Civil Society After the Full-Scale Invasion of Ukraine. International Centre for Defence and Security (ICDS).
Isril. (2024). National road access in the Anai Valley, West Sumatra, has reopened. Antaranews.Com. https://en.antaranews.com/news/319380/national-road-access-in-the-anai-valley-west-sumatra-has-reopened
Istijono, B., Yuhendra, R., Hape, M. T., Mahdi, M., Dodi, A., Al Giffari, M., Hakam, A., Adji, B. M., & Menghoung, S. (2025). National road cliff protection analysis in Malibau Anai after Anai River flood, West Sumatra. E3S Web of Conferences, 604, 1005.
Lang, S., Füreder, P., Kranz, O., Card, B., Roberts, S., & Papp, A. (2024). 7 Humanitarian Emergencies. Remote Sensing Handbook, Volume VI: Droughts, Disasters, Pollution, and Urban Mapping, 199.
Lipiäinen, S. (2024). A New Age for a New Burma: Decolonial Discourse and National Aspirations in post-WWII Burma.
Maria Cicilia Galuh P, Nabil Ihsan, A. K. (2026). Adequate aid reaches Sumatra flood victims without emergency status. Antaranews.Com. https://en.antaranews.com/news/398203/adequate-aid-reaches-sumatra-flood-victims-without-emergency-status
Mayasari, S., Wulandari, C., Sukohar, A., & Bakri, S. (2024). BNPB Performance in Disaster Management in Indonesia: Follow-up Recommendations. Justicia Sains: Jurnal Ilmu Hukum, 9(2), 530–540.
Migdal, J. S. (2018). The state in society. In New directions in comparative politics (pp. 63–79). Routledge.
Mosurska, A., Clark-Ginsberg, A., Sallu, S., & Ford, J. D. (2023). Disasters and indigenous peoples: A critical discourse analysis of the expert news media. Environment and Planning E: Nature and Space, 6(1), 178–201.
Mukhlis, M. M. (2025). Regional Government Autonomy in Indonesia: The Ambiguity of the Federalism of Republic Model. Malaysian J. Syariah & L., 13, 35.
Office of Assistant to Deputy Cabinet. (2024). President Jokowi Orders Quick Response to Cold Lava Flow in W. Sumatra. 14 Mei. https://setkab.go.id/en/president-jokowi-orders-quick-response-to-cold-lava-flow-in-w-sumatra/
Perdana Putra, G. K. (2024). Tanggap Darurat Bencana Sumbar Berakhir, Kerugian Total Rp 516 Miliar. Regional.Kompas.Com. https://regional.kompas.com/read/2024/06/10/145412178/tanggap-darurat-bencana-sumbar-berakhir-kerugian-total-rp-516-miliar
Peters, B. G. (2018). The politics of bureaucracy: An introduction to comparative public administration. Routledge.
Purwaningsih, E., Liusti, S. A., Purnamasari, E., Ramadhan, R., & Nasution, A. F. R. (2024). The Mount Marapi eruption disaster evacuation path model using a local wisdom approach. GEOMATE Journal, 26(116), 64–71.
Putra, D. I. (2019). Study on disaster management system under decentralization system in Indonesia.
Reichstein, M., Benson, V., Blunk, J., Camps-Valls, G., Creutzig, F., Fearnley, C. J., Han, B., Kornhuber, K., Rahaman, N., & Schölkopf, B. (2025). Early warning of complex climate risk with integrated artificial intelligence. Nature Communications, 16(1), 2564.
Ridzuan, N. Q. M., & Maiddin, S. H. M. (2024). Road Development in Five Malaysian Plan, 1966-1990. SEJARAH: Journal of the Department of History, 33(1 (June)).
Riffe, D., Lacy, S., Watson, B. R., & Lovejoy, J. (2023). Analyzing media messages: Using quantitative content analysis in research. Routledge.
Roslimah, R., Susanti, N. M., Putra, M. A., & Haris, A. (2024). Karakteristik Alat Tangkap Gurita Yang di Pakai Nelayan Secara Alami Dapat Melindungi Ekosistem Terumbu Karang di Kabupaten Simeulue. Zoologi: Jurnal Ilmu Peternakan, Ilmu Perikanan, Ilmu Kedokteran Hewan, 2(2), 112–122.
Sayers, E. W., Agarwala, R., Bolton, E. E., Brister, J. R., Canese, K., Clark, K., Connor, R., Fiorini, N., Funk, K., & Hefferon, T. (2019). Database resources of the national center for biotechnology information. Nucleic Acids Research, 47(D1), D23–D28.
Sellers, J. S., & Scharff, E. A. (2020). Preempting politics: State power and local democracy. Stan. L. Rev., 72, 1361.
Shofa, J. N. (2025). Indonesia Loses $4.1 Billion from Sumatra Floods as Death Toll Climbs to 631. Jakartaglobe.Id. https://jakartaglobe.id/business/indonesia-loses-41-billion-from-sumatra-floods-as-death-toll-climbs-to-631
Suppasri, A., Muhari, A., Yunus, R., Pakoksung, K., Imamura, F., Koshimura, S., & Paulik, R. (2018). Vulnerability characteristics of tsunamis in Indonesia: Analysis of the global centre for disaster statistics database. Journal of Disaster Research, 13(6), 1039–1048.
Tanesab, J. P. (2020). Institutional effectiveness and inclusions: public perceptions on Indonesia’s disaster management authorities. International Journal of Disaster Management, 3(2), 1–15.
Tran, V. (2023). A narrative inquiry into Vietnamese migrants’ experiences of disaster risk reduction. Open Access Te Herenga Waka-Victoria University of Wellington.
Turkson, A. M. (2023). Relationship between former Liberian refugees and the host community in Buduburam after the end of humanitarian assistance. University of Education, Winneba.
UMY. (2025). Why Haven’t the Sumatra Floods Been Considered a National Disaster Yet? UMY Expert Explains. Umy.Ac.Id. https://www.umy.ac.id/en/mengapa-banjir-sumatera-belum-jadi-bencana-nasional-ini-penjelasan-pakar-umy/
Van Hulst, M., Metze, T., Dewulf, A., De Vries, J., Van Bommel, S., & Van Ostaijen, M. (2025). Discourse, framing and narrative: three ways of doing critical, interpretive policy analysis. Critical Policy Studies, 19(1), 74–96.
Van Klinken, G. (2006). Colonizing Borneo: state-building and ethnicity in Central Kalimantan. Indonesia, 81, 23–49.
